
Okay, so I’m at an author luncheon yesterday being hosted by the good folks at Houghton Mifflin.
Sitting around the table is a nice little grouping of who’s who in the Boston kid-books scene, including Roger Sutton of the Horn Book, Carol Stoltz from Porter Square Books, the wonderful Anita Silvey, poetess extraordinare Joyce Sidman, (if you have seen her latest book of apology poems, check it out), and the hard-working Alison Morris from Wellesley Booksmith and PW blogger fame.
Apropos of my essay below, the conversation turned to self-published children’s books and customer reviews on websites, and Alison brought the above to my attention. Props to her, because I think this is just about the funniest thing I have ever seen on Amazon.
Self-published authors, take note.
Published in 1990 via Vantage Press, a notorious vanity publisher, LATAWNYA, the Naughty Horse, Learns to Say “NO” to Drugs is the story of a—well—a naughty horse named Latawnya. And her sisters Latoya and Daisy. And how they run into four other horses Connie, Crystal, Jackie and Angie who are all playing a “smoking game and a drinking game”. But wait, why paraphrase when you can read the whole book for yourself. Go ahead.
Here’s my favorite part:


Now putting aside the amazing writing for a minute, let’s just meditate on the image of one horse slapping the alcohol and drugs out of another horse’s HOOF. I swear I laughed so hard I cried.
And if the book itself makes you laugh, be sure to read the reviews on Amazon. Like this one:
Thank you Latawna!
I used to be an alcoholic, drug-addicted AND naughty horse.
But thanks to this inspired work ( thank you God ),
I am not a horse anymore.
So, who is this author? Perhaps she herself has had a bad brush with “smoking drugs”.

Lest you think I am making fun of the message here, I am not. It’s a very important message.
I have also occasionally thanked God, but not twice in the same bio.
This is the perfect example of how a great message can be completely overshadowed by a bad delivery. It’s like proposing marriage in a clown suit. In this particular case, we have a work that is so bad it’s genius, and like Snakes on a Plane, it’s poised for cult fame.
Maybe Sylvia should put it back in print, because she might make some money on it finally.
Listen up, people. It’s not the drug smoking horses you have to be afraid of, it’s having a story like this make you the butt of jokes on Amazon for years.
Save yourselves. Just say no.
***
Many thanks to Walker B over at The Something Awful Forums for first making this available to the wider public after he found it in the elementary school library where he works. This deserves to see the light of day, if only to serve as a warning to others.

17 comments
Comments feed for this article
August 23, 2007 at 12:18 pm
Debbie
HA HA HA HA HA HA!! I don’t just want this book, I NEED this book.
Perhaps Latawnya would have found smoking drugs and drinking alcohol a lot easier if she did it without someone smacking it out of her hoof all the damn time. She might also find it better to use both hooves so she can get a better draw without having to worry about spilling her Colt 45.
This book is a multi-layered cake of badness, the most delicious being the pitting of “Latawnya, Latoya and Daisy” against “Connie, Crystal, Jackie and Angie”. Because now I’m picturing horsified versions of Connie Francis, Crystal Gayle, Jackie Collins, and Angie Dickenson trying to corrupt two home girls and a ditzy southern gal in short-shorts.
I would like to say that the image of these wanton she-horses sparking up will live with me forever. “The image of these wanton she-horses sparking up will live with me forever.”
And what, exactly, did she co-invent?
August 23, 2007 at 5:41 pm
cat
I laughed so hard that my co-worker came to check on me.
August 23, 2007 at 10:54 pm
Celise
Now, see? This is the very reason why self-publishing gets such a bad rap. I self-pubbed my first two books and I know for a fact that mine are better than this.
Despite the bad rap, it was good for a laff. Thank you. I needed that.
August 24, 2007 at 5:57 am
Kathy
What I want to know is how and where did all the people who left these hilarious comments find the book in the first place? Amazing.
August 24, 2007 at 9:18 am
kmclean
The book had some buzz this spring after it was posted on a forum. I think people went to Amazon after they saw it there.
August 30, 2007 at 1:28 pm
Thoughts On Stuff » Blog Archive » To all the writers I know
[...] Stephanie just sent me the manuscript for her very first novel. And just now I read a hilarious blog post about the dangers of smoking drugs (and self [...]
September 28, 2007 at 11:30 am
BITTER
Who should play Latawnya in the film version? I say Sarah Jessica Parker.
December 13, 2007 at 3:44 pm
m
Re: “the perfect example of how a great message can be completely overshadowed by a bad delivery,” I’d nominate the phrase “if you have seen her latest book of apology poems, check it out.”
March 13, 2008 at 10:51 am
Agate (or “What good is a picture book?” Really good.) « pixie stix kids pix
[...] you have been reading pixiestix for awhile you are probably aware of my feelings about marginal books that are either self-published, or that are produced by small presses that don’t quite get how to [...]
March 14, 2008 at 6:36 pm
latawnya, the naughty horse, learns to say ‘no’ to drugs
[...] Thanks Meg for the link and Pixie Stix [...]
May 22, 2008 at 4:07 pm
Anastasia Burke
Thsi absolutely had me howling. I am clutching tissue, trying to keep the tears from spalshing all over my keyboard.
I just hate it when I catch my horses smoking and drinking and carrying on. What’s next…sneaking the collts into the barn?
On a more serious note, I am a widely published freelancer writer with national creds–and have written a YA novel about girls and horses that I post on my blog one chapter at a time. This version of self-publishing is in hopes of channeling Scott Fitzgerald’s “Saturday Evening Post” success. Big dreams, eh?
I strive to keep the writing great–but as Latawnya’s author proves, self publishers are notorious for simply writing what they think sounds good–or good enough, at any rate. Without the oversight of a good editor, things can go very, very wrong.
I will keep Latawnya in mind always as a cautionary tale, not about what happens when good horses go bad, but about how easily a writer can embarrass herself.
June 18, 2008 at 1:37 pm
Tips for success in the children’s book industry « pixie stix kids pix
[...] not write about your dog, your grandkids, horses, rainbows, puppies, feelings, or fairies. Be careful about wizards [...]
August 17, 2008 at 4:01 pm
Agate:What Good is a Moose? « Once Upon a Story….
[...] you have been reading pixiestix for awhile you are probably aware of my feelings about marginal books that are either self-published, or that are produced by small presses that don’t quite get how to [...]
August 27, 2008 at 11:53 am
amy goldman koss
Thanks!
September 25, 2008 at 2:46 pm
Wow. Just…wow « Portal to the Internets
[...] PIXIE STIX KIDS PIX via GAWKER, I shit you not, a book about drug-addicted alcoholic HORSES, aimed at [...]
September 26, 2008 at 12:09 am
How Horses Learn To Say “No” To Drugs | Delicious Ghost
[...] but only today did we get a tip from DG superfriend Jessica to check out the best anti-drug book ever published. A trio of African-American horses start drinking and smoking drugs, but Latawnya learns to say [...]
September 28, 2008 at 2:04 am
Sunday Link Du Jour: Possibly the Craziest Book Ever « 100 Scope Notes
[...] Children’s book blog Pixie Stix Kids Picks first brought it to my attention. [...]